格莱美的古典音乐奖实在没有什么公信力
Best Engineered Album, Classical
得奖:
Mahler: Symphony No. 8; Adagio From Symphony No. 10
Peter Laenger, engineer (Michael Tilson Thomas & San Francisco Symphony)
[SFS Media]
提名:
Britten: Billy Budd
Neil
Hutchinson & Jonathan Stokes, engineers (Daniel Harding, Nathan
Gunn, Ian Bostridge, Gidon Saks, Neal Davies, Jonathan Lemalu, Matthew
Rose, London Symphony Chorus & London Symphony Orchestra)
[Virgin Classics]
QSF Plays Brubeck
Judy Kirschner, engineer (Quartet San Francisco)
[Violinjazz Recordings]
Ravel: Daphnis Et Chloé
Jesse Lewis & John Newton, engineers (James Levine, Tanglewood Festival Chorus & Boston Symphony Orchestra)
[BSO Classics]
Shostakovich: Symphonies Nos. 1 & 15
John Newton & Dirk Sobotka, engineers (Valery Gergiev & Orchestra Of The Mariinsky Theatre)
[Mariinsky]
Producer Of The Year, Classical
得奖:
Steven Epstein
- Adams: Doctor Atomic Symphony (David Robertson & Saint Louis Symphony Orchestra)
- Bernstein: Mass (Marin Alsop, Jubilant Sykes, Asher Edward Wulfman,
Morgan State University Choir, Peabody Children's Chorus &
Baltimore Symphony Orchestra) - Corigliano: A Dylan Thomas Trilogy (Leonard Slatkin, George Mabry,
Sir Thomas Allen, Nashville Symphony Chorus & Nashville Symphony
Orchestra) - Fauré: Piano Quintets (Fine Arts Quartet & Cristina Oritz)
- Yo-Yo Ma & Friends: Songs Of Joy And Peace (Yo-Yo Ma & Various Artists)
提名:
Blanton Alspaugh
- Carlson, David: Anna Karenina (Stewart Robertson, Christine
Abraham, Sarah Colburn, Robert Gierlach, Christian Van Horn, Kelly
Kaduce, Opera Theatre Of Saint Louis & Saint Louis Symphony
Orchestra) - Menotti: Amahl And The Night Visitors; My Christmas (Alastair
Willis, Ike Hawkersmith, Kirsten Gunlogson, Dean Anthony, Todd Thomas,
Kevin Short, Bart LeFan, Chicago Symphony Chorus, Nashville Symphony
Chorus & Nashville Symphony Orchestra) - Ravel: L'Enfant Et Les Sortilèges (Alastair Willis, Julie
Boulianne, Chicago Symphony Chorus, Chattanooga Boys Choir, Nashville
Symphony Chorus & Nashville Symphony Orchestra) - Schubert: Death And The Maiden (JoAnn Falletta &; Buffalo Philharmonic Orchestra)
- Sierra, Roberto: Missa Latina 'Pro Pace' (Andreas Delfs, Nathaniel
Webster, Heidi Grant Murphy, Milwaukee Symphony Chorus & Milwaukee
Symphony Orchestra)
John Fraser
- Britten: Billy Budd (Daniel Harding, Nathan Gunn, Ian Bostridge,
Gidon Saks, Neal Davies, Jonathan Lemalu, Matthew Rose, London Symphony
Chorus & London Symphony Orchestra) - Midsummer Night (Kate Royal, Edward Gardner, Crouch End Festival Chorus & Orchestra Of English National Opera)
- Schubert: Schwanengesang (Ian Bostridge & Antonio Pappano)
- Shadows Of Silence (Leif Ove Andsnes, Franz Welzer-Möst & Sinfonieorchester Des Bayerischen Rundfunks)
David Frost
- An American Journey (Eroica Trio)
- Journey To The New World (Sharon Isbin, Mark O'Connor & Joan Baez)
- Korngold: Violin Concerto; Schauspiel Overture; Much Ado About
Nothing (Philippe Quint, Carlos Miguel Prieto & Orquesta Sinfonica
de Mineria) - Mozart: Piano Concertos 21 & 22 (Jonathan Biss & Orpheus Chamber Orchestra)
- O'Connor, Mark: String Quartets Nos. 2 & 3 (Ida Kavafian, Mark O'Connor, Paul Neubauer & Matt Haimovitz)
James Mallinson
- MacMillan, James: St. John Passion (Sir Colin Davis, Christopher
Maltman, London Symphony Chorus & London Symphony Orchestra) - Mahler: Symphony No. 8 (Valery Gergiev, Choir Of Eltham College,
Choral Arts Society Of Washington, London Symphony Chorus & London
Symphony Orchestra) - Shostakovich: Symphonies Nos. 1 & 15 (Valery Gergiev & Orchestra Of The Mariinsky Theatre)
- Shostakovich: The Nose (Valery Gergiev, Andrei Popov, Sergei
Semishkur, Vladislav Sulimsky, Chorus Of The Mariinsky Theatre &
Orchestra Of The Mariinsky Theatre)
Best Classical Album
Award to the Artist(s) and to the Album Producer(s) if other than the Artist.
得奖:
Mahler: Symphony No. 8; Adagio From Symphony No. 10
Michael Tilson Thomas, conductor; Ragnar Bohlin, Kevin Fox & Susan McMane, choir directors; Andreas Neubronner, producer;
Peter Laenger, engineer/mixer; Andreas Neubronner, mastering engineer (Laura Claycomb, Anthony Dean Griffey, Katarina Karnéus, Quinn Kelsey, James Morris, Yvonne Naef, Elza van den Heever & Erin Wall; San Francisco Symphony; Pacific Boychoir, San Francisco Girls Chorus & San Francisco Symphony Chorus)
[SFS Media]
提名:
Bernstein: Mass
Marin Alsop, conductor; Jubilant Sykes; Steven Epstein, producer; Richard King, engineer/mixer (Asher Edward Wulfman; Baltimore Symphony Orchestra; Morgan State University Choir & Peabody Children's Chorus)
[Naxos]
Ravel: Daphnis Et Chloé
James Levine, conductor; Elizabeth Ostrow, producer; Jesse Lewis & John Newton, engineers/mixers; Mark Donahue, mastering engineer (Boston Symphony Orchestra; Tanglewood Festival Chorus)
[BSO Classics]
Ravel: L'Enfant Et Les Sortilèges
Alastair Willis, conductor; Julie Boulianne; Blanton Alspaugh, producer; Mark Donahue & John Hill, engineers/mixers (Nashville Symphony Orchestra; Chattanooga Boys Choir, Chicago Symphony Chorus & Nashville Symphony Chorus)
[Naxos]
Shostakovich: The Nose
Valery Gergiev, conductor; Andrei Popov, Sergei Semishkur & Vladislav Sulimsky; James Mallinson, producer; John Newton & Dirk Sobotka, engineers/mixers; Mark Donahue, mastering engineer (Orchestra Of The Mariinsky Theatre; Chorus Of The Mariinsky Theatre)
[Mariinsky]
Best Orchestral Performance
Award to the Conductor and to the Orchestra.
得奖:
Ravel: Daphnis Et Chloé
James Levine, conductor (Boston Symphony Orchestra; Tanglewood Festival Chorus)
[BSO Classics]
提名:
Berlioz: Symphonie Fantastique
Simon Rattle, conductor (Susan Graham; Berliner Philharmoniker)
[EMI Classics]
Bruckner: Symphony No. 5
Benjamin Zander, conductor (Philharmonia Orchestra)
[Telarc]
Shostakovich: Symphonies Nos. 1 & 15
Valery Gergiev, conductor (Orchestra Of The Mariinsky Theatre)
[Mariinsky]
Szymanowski: Symphonies Nos. 1 & 4
Antoni Wit, conductor (Jan Krzysztof Broja, Ewa Marczyk & Marek Marczyk; Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra)
[Naxos]
Best Opera Recording
Award to the Conductor, Album Producer(s) and Principal Soloists.
得奖:
Britten: Billy Budd
Daniel Harding, conductor; Ian Bostridge, Neal Davies, Nathan Gunn, Jonathan Lemalu, Matthew Rose & Gidon Saks; John Fraser, producer (London Symphony Orchestra; Gentlemen Of The London Symphony Chorus)
[Virgin Classics]
提名:
Messiaen: Saint François D'Assise
Ingo Metzmacher, conductor; Armand Arapian, Hubert Delamboye, Rod Gilfry, Henk Neven, Tom Randle & Camilla Tilling; Ferenc van Damme, producer (The Hague Philharmonic; Chorus Of De Nederlandse Opera)
[Opus Arte]
Musto, John: Volpone
Sara Jobin, conductor; Anne-Carolyn Bird, Lisa Hopkins, Joshua Jeremiah, Museop Kim, Jeremy Little, Rodell Rosel, Steven Sanders & Faith Sherman; Blanton Alspaugh, producer (Wolf Trap Opera Company)
[Wolf Trap Recordings]
Shostakovich: The Nose
Valery Gergiev, conductor; Andrei Popov, Sergei Semishkur & Vladislav Sulimsky; James Mallinson, producer (Orchestra Of The Mariinsky Theatre; Chorus Of The Mariinsky Theatre)
[Mariinsky]
Tan Dun: Marco Polo
Tan Dun, conductor; Stephen Bryant, Sarah Castle, Zhang Jun, Nancy Allen Lundy, Stephen Richardson & Charles Workman; Ferenc van Damme, producer (Netherlands Chamber Orchestra; Cappella Amsterdam)
[Opus Arte]
Best Choral Performance
Award to the Choral Conductor, and to the Orchestra Conductor if an Orchestra is on the recording, and to the Choral Director or Chorus Master if applicable.
得奖:
Mahler: Symphony No. 8; Adagio From Symphony No. 10
Michael Tilson Thomas, conductor; Ragnar Bohlin, Kevin Fox & Susan McMane, choir directors
(Laura Claycomb, Anthony Dean Griffey, Elza van den Heever, Katarina Karnéus, Quinn Kelsey, James Morris, Yvonne Naef & Erin Wall; San Francisco Symphony; Pacific Boychoir, San Francisco Symphony Chorus & San Francisco Girls Chorus)
[SFS Media]
提名:
Handel: Coronation Anthems
Harry Christophers, conductor (Alastair Ross; The Sixteen Orchestra; The Sixteen)
[CORO]
Penderecki: Utrenja
Antoni Wit, conductor
(Gennady Bezzubenkov, Iwona Hossa, Piotr Kusiewicz, Piotr Nowacki & Agnieszka Rehlis; Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra; Warsaw Boys' Choir & Warsaw Philharmonic Choir)
[Naxos]
Song Of The Stars: Granados, Casals & Blancafort
Dennis Keene, conductor (Erica Kiesewetter; Mark Kruczek & Douglas Riva; Voices Of Ascension)
[Naxos]
A Spotless Rose
Paul McCreesh, conductor (The Gabrieli Consort)
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Best Instrumental Soloist(s) Performance (With Orchestra)
Award to the Instrumental Soloist(s) and to the Conductor.
得奖:
Prokofiev: Piano Concertos Nos. 2 & 3
Vladimir Ashkenazy, conductor; Evgeny Kissin (Philharmonia Orchestra)
[EMI Classics]
提名:
Bartók: 3 Concertos
Pierre Boulez, conductor (Pierre-Laurent Aimard, Yuri Bashmet, Gidon Kremer, Neil Percy, Tamara Stefanovich & Nigel Thomas; Berliner Philharmoniker & London Symphony Orchestra)
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Bermel, Derek: Voices For Solo Clarinet And Orchestra
Gil Rose, conductor; Derek Bermel (Boston Modern Orchestra Project)
Track from: Bermel, Derek: Voices
[BMOP/Sound]
Korngold: Violin Concerto In D Major, Op. 35
Carlos Miguel Prieto, conductor; Philippe Quint (Orquesta Sinfónica de Mineria)
Track from: Korngold Violin Concerto; Schauspiel Overture; Much Ado About Nothing
[Naxos]
Salonen, Esa-Pekka: Piano Concerto
Esa-Pekka Salonen, conductor; Yefim Bronfman (Los Angeles Philharmonic)
Track from: Salonen
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Best Instrumental Soloist Performance (Without Orchestra)
Award to the Instrumental Soloist.
得奖:
Journey To The New World
Sharon Isbin (Joan Baez & Mark O'Connor)
[Sony Classical]
提名:
Caroline Goulding
Caroline Goulding (Christopher O'Riley & Janine Randall)
[Telarc]
Chopin
Maria João Pires
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Oppens Plays Carter
Ursula Oppens
[Cedille Records]
Sonatas & Etudes
Yuja Wang
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Best Chamber Music Performance
Award to the Artists.
得奖:
Intimate Letters
Emerson String Quartet
[Deutsche Grammophon]
提名:
Ginastera: String Quartets (Complete)
Enso Quartet (Lucy Shelton)
[Naxos]
The Hungarian Album
Guarneri Quartet
[RCA Red Seal]
Schumann/Bartók: The Berlin Recital
Martha Argerich & Gidon Kremer
[EMI Classics]
Takemitsu, Toru: And Then I Knew 'Twas Wind
Yolanda Kondonassis, Cynthia Phelps & Joshua Smith
Track from: Debussy & Takemitsu: Air: Music For Harp, Flute & Strings
[TELARC]
Best Small Ensemble Performance
Award to the Ensemble (and to the Conductor.)
得奖:
Lang, David: The Little Match Girl Passion
Paul Hillier, conductor; Ars Nova Copenhagen & Theatre Of Voices
[Harmonia Mundi]
提名:
Bach: Orchestral Suites For A Young Prince
Monica Huggett, conductor; Gonzalo X. Ruiz; Ensemble Sonnerie
[Avie Records]
Josquin: Missa Malheur Me Bat
Peter Phillips, conductor; Tallis Scholars
[Gimell]
Song Of Songs
Stile Antico (Alison Hill & Benedict Hymas)
[harmonia mundi]
Vivaldi: Concertos
Daniel Hope & Anne Sofie von Otter; Chamber Orchestra Of Europe (Kristian Bezuidenhout)
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Best Classical Vocal Performance
Award to the Vocal Soloist(s).
得奖:
Verismo Arias
Renée Fleming (Marco Armiliato; Jonas Kaufmann; Orchestra Sinfonica Di Milano Giuseppi Verdi; Coro Sinfonica Di Milano Giuseppi Verdi)
[Decca]
提名:
Bach
Anne Sofie von Otter (Lars Ulrik Mortensen; Anders J. Dahlin, Jakob Bloch Jespersen, Tomas Medici & Karin Roman; Concerto Copenhagen)
[Deutsche Grammophon]
Bel Canto Spectacular
Juan Diego Flórez (Daniel Oren; Daniella Barcellona, Patrizia Ciofi, Plácido Domingo, Mariusz Kwiecien, Anna Netrebko & Fernando Piqueras; Orquestra De La Comunitat Valenciana; Cor De La Generalitat Valenciana)
[Decca]
Recital At Ravinia
Lorraine Hunt Lieberson (Drew Minter; Peter Serkin)
[Harmonia Mundi]
Un Frisson Français
Susan Graham (Malcom Martineau)
[Onyx Classics]
Best Classical Contemporary Composition
A Composer's Award. (For a contemporary classical composition composed within the last 25 years, and released for the first time during the Eligibility Year.) Award to the librettist, if applicable.
得奖:
Higdon, Jennifer: Percussion Concerto
Jennifer Higdon (Marin Alsop)
Track from: Alsop Conducts MacMillan, Ad
[London Philharmonic Orchestra]
提名:
Crumb, George: The Winds Of Destiny
George Crumb (James Freeman)
Track from: Crumb: American Songbooks 2 & 4
[Bridge Records]
Pärt, Arvo: In Principio
Arvo Pärt (Tõnu Kaljuste)
Track from: P
[ECM New Series]
Sierra, Roberto: Missa Latina 'Pro Pace'
Roberto Sierra (Andreas Delfs)
[Naxos]
Wyner, Yehudi: Piano Concerto "Chiavi In Mano"
Yehudi Wyner (Robert Spano)
Track from: Wyner, Yehudi: Orchestral Works
[Bridge Records]
Best Classical Crossover Album
Award to the Artist(s) and/or to the Conductor.
得奖:
Yo-Yo Ma & Friends: Songs Of Joy And Peace
Yo-Yo Ma
(Odair Assad, Sergio Assad, Chris Botti, Dave Brubeck, Matt Brubeck, John Clayton, Paquito d'Rivera, Renée Fleming, Diana Krall, Alison Krauss, Natalie McMaster, Edgar Meyer, Cristina Pato, Joshua Redman, Jake Shimabukuro, Silk Road Ensemble, James Taylor, Chris Thile, Wu Tong, Alon Yavnai & Amelia Zirin-Brown)
[Sony Classical]
提名:
A Company Of Voices: Conspirare In Concert
Craig Hella Johnson, conductor; Conspirare (Tom Burritt, Ian Davidson & Bion Tsang)
[Harmonia Mundi]
Jazz-Clazz
Paquito D'Rivera Quintet (Trio Clarone)
[TIMBA Records]
The Melody Of Rhythm
Leonard Slatkin, conductor; Béla Fleck, Zakir Hussain & Edgar Meyer (Detroit Symphony Orchestra)
[E1 Music]
QSF Plays Brubeck
Quartet San Francisco
[Violinjazz Recordings]
Twelve Songs By Charles Ives
Theo Bleckmann; Kneebody
[Winter & Winter]
评论
2010-02-02 10:27
2010-02-02 12:08
普通受众的鉴赏力一旦缺失,这门艺术的鉴别就成了纯业内的事情。在道德底线高的地方,比赛结果就成了学术权威的个人审美的体现;在道德底线低的地方,就成了分猪肉;在没有道德底线的地方,就成了权钱色交易的平台。古今中外皆如是。
电影比赛之所以还具有较强的公正性,是因为电影的广大受众还有鉴赏力,电影行业还要靠这些受众支撑的票房吃饭,得罪不起。至于那些反正也是靠政府拨款、巨企资助苟延残喘的艺术门类,当然就要看政府和巨企的眼色了,反正选出来什么阿猫阿狗对于老百姓都是一样的。
蝉雏
2010-02-02 14:06
古典音乐的 “劲歌”颁奖典礼,亲生仔女当然要照顾,我们都只能希望唱片公司做点好唱片出来就满足了。
bb
2010-02-12 21:43
唱片看适合自己口味波?什么奖项啦理都不要理,更不能跟着奖项买唱片,和自己钱包过不去。
音乐虫子
















2010-02-02 08:59
分析一下结果,MTT的马勒和Sony唱片公司分别获得三个奖项成为再次成为大赢家,之后,BSO是一个,EMI两个(EMI和Virgin各一个),环球两个(DGG和Decca各一个),Harmonia Mundi一个,LPO一个。难为grammy,在仅有十多个奖项里面,分猪肉分得这样辛苦,Sony老大是不能得罪(grammy就是CBS转播的),MTT之类的美国英雄是要照顾的,BSO有向grammy抛媚眼,也要给点面子,CSO的作风欧洲化,一向不尿grammy,所以很久没给CSO了,华纳是sony老大的对手,也不能给,EMI环球之类的大集团是要给的,但是都给一个品牌,那么会显得美国的公司与乐团不行,那么就给一个正牌,一个副牌,而且两个集团的得奖数量要一样,至于harmonia mundi之类的公司,明知有好的表现,但是都不能把奖颁给年度最杰出的品种,LPO之类的获奖是用来平衡的。所以入选的欧洲品种基本上都不是去年表现卓越的品种。还是对比一下midem的结果或者BBC正在投票选举吧。
希望以上是小人之心吧。
在所谓的四大古典唱片大奖,现在最没公信力是grammy,其次是gramophone。就是分猪肉的心态,导致媒体丧失了自己的公信力,或者说是彻底倾向商家而不是照顾消费者的利益,那么这样的评奖必将会被消费者所唾弃。
QnA