Symphony No. 5 in d minor， Op. 47
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1937/11/21 in Leningrad
1938/3/27 to 4/3， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: unknown
MRAVINSKY’S FIRST RECORDING
78: Old Melodiya 06820/33， 14 sides WERM1-559
CD: BMG(Japan) B0CC 3 (1998)， bonus disc in 4 disc set
This recording was broadcast on BBC Radio 3 on 1994/11/15. Melodiya does not have any original source of this recording.
late 1938 to early 1939， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: unknown
MRAVINSKY’S FIRST RECORDING AFTER BEING APPOINTED CHIEF CONDUCTOR OF THE LENINGRAD PHILHARMONIC
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 8020 (1998)， 4 disc set
1954/4/3， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: David Gaklin
LP: Old Melodiya D 02283/4 (1954) B-560， WERM3-426
LP: Ariola SQ 89519XDK (1976)， 2 disc set
CD: BMG 74321-29404-2 (1996)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4016 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 5075 (1977)
LP: JVC VICX 1006 (1979)， 10 disc set
CD: JVC VDC 25004 (1988)
LP: Kawade-shobo/Shinsekai SKV 1101 (1971)， 2 disc set
CD: Pigeon GX 248
LP: Shinsekai LS 4 (1956)
LP: Shinsekai PX 5501 (1961)
LP: Shinsekai PX 8539 (1964)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7583 (1965)， Electronic simulated stereo
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7592 (1970)， Electronic simulated stereo
LP: Shinsekai MK 1022 (1973)
LP: Vanguard VRS 6025 (1956)
Ariola SQ 89519XDK incorrectly claims this is the live recording on 1954/4/26 in Moscow.
1965/11/24， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: na
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10910 (1995)
1966， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: na
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 11023 (1993)
CD: Audiophile APL 101.503 (1994)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Audiophile APL 101.503 and Russian Disc RDCD 11023 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. Audiophile APL 101.503 incorrectly dated 1983.
Unknown date， Spring Festival in Prague， Live， Monaural； RE: na
CD: Hunt 2HUNTCD 714 (1990)， 2 disc set
CD: Arkadia CDGI 714.2， 2 disc set
Hunt 2HUNTCD 714 and Arkadia CDGI 714.2 incorrectly dated 1968. Mravinsky and the Leningrad Philharmonic did not visit Prague in 1968. Probably the date is 1967.
1973/6/29， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: na
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 11180 (1994)
The recording date was given by Aleksandr Nevzorov (Mravinsky’s last pupil).
1978/6/13， Vienna， Grosser Musikvereinssaal， Live； RE: Arfred Tsafrel
LP: Ariola 300666 in 300668-400 (1980)， 4 disc set
CD: Ariola 880028-910
LP: HMV ASD 4028 SLS 5212 (1980)， 4 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 2324 (1981)， 4 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 28017 (1981)
CT: JVC VCC 10006
CD: JVC VDC 1007 (1985)
CD: JVC VICC 40118 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Melodiya S10 15321/2 (1981)
CD: Praga PR 250085 (1994)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46021-2 (1994)
Daisuke Kisagami indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 250085 is identical with JVC VDC 1007， since the timings of the individual movements are same， and the coughs in the first movement are placed in the same places. Praga PR 250085 incorrectly claims to have been recorded on 1967/5/26 in Prague.
Symphony No. 6 in b minor， Op. 54
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1939/11/5 in Leningrad
1946/11/4， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: unknown
LP: Old Melodiya D 2488/9 (1955)， 25cm B-560
LP: Melodiya D 030616 (1971) B-560
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4016 (1997)
LP: Chant du Monde LDXA 8267， 25cm
LP: JVC VIC 5076 (1977)
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7595 (1970)
LP: Shinsekai MK 1023 (1973)
1965/2/21， Grand Hall of Moscow Conservatory， Live； RE: Igor Veprintsev
LP: Melodiya SM 02857 (1971) B-560
LP: Melodiya S10 12955/6 (1980)
LP: Melodiya S60 12957/8 (1980): 2nd and 3rd movements only
LP: Angel SR 40202 (1972)
LP: Ariola 80586KK
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4028 (1997)
LP: HMV ASD 2805 (1972)
CD: Icone ICN 9404-2 (1994)
LP: JVC VIC 5068 (1977)
CD: JVC VICC 40118 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7711 (1972)
LP: Shinsekai MKX 2011 (1975)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46156-2 (1995)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46157-2 (1995)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that JVC VICC 40118， Icone ICN 9404-2， ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46156-2 and MEL 46157-2 are all identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. Icone ICN 9404-2 incorrectly claims to have been recorded at the Concert Hall of the Moscow Radio on 1983/3/12. JVC VICC 40118 incorrectly dated 1965/2/25.
1972/1/27， Grand Hall of Moscow Conservatory， Live； RE: Igor Veprintsev
CD: BMG 74321-25198-2 (1995)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 (1996)
CD: Praga PR 254017 (1994)
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10910 (1995)
Hiroshi Yasuda indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 254017 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 are identical， since the coughs in the second movement occur in the same places. Praga PR 254017 incorrectly claims to have been recorded on 1955/5/21 in Prague. Russian Disc RDCD 10910 incorrectly claims to have been recorded at the Grand Hall of the Leningrad Philharmonic.
Symphony No. 7 in C， "Leningrad"， Op. 60
<1953/2/26， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: Ilya Grodzensky
LP: Old Melodiya D 01380/3 (1953)， 2 discs B-560， WERM3-426
LP: Melodiya D 033449/51 (1972)， 3 sides in 2 disc set B-560
CD: BMG 74321-29405-2 (1996)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4017 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 5077/8 (1977)， 2 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40119 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Shinsekai PLS 28/9 (1957)， 2 disc set
LP: Shinsekai PX 8557/8 (1965)， 3 sides in 2 disc set
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7593/4 (1970)， 2 disc set
LP: Shinsekai MK 1024/5 (1973)， 2 disc set
LP: Vanguard VRS 6030/1 (1957)， 3 sides in 2 disc set
The recording date was given by Aleksandr Nevzorov (Mravinsky’s last pupil).
JVC VICC 40119 dated 1953/2/26.
Symphony No. 8 in c minor， Op. 65
Dedicated to Mravinsky
World premiere by Mravinsky/USSR State Symphony Orchestra on 1943/11/4 in Moscow
1947/6/2， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: Ilya Grodzensky
LP: Old Melodiya D 03620/1 (1957) B-560
LP: Melodiya D 032639/40 (1972) B-560
LP: Ariola SQ 89519XDK (1976)， 3 sides in 2 disc set
LP: Artia MK 219B (1964)， 2 disc set
CD: BMG 74321-29406-2 (1996)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4018 (1997)
CD: JVC VICC 40120 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Shinsekai MK 1081 (1975)
1960/9/23， London， Royal Festival Hall， Live， the Composer in attendance； RE: na
CD: BBC Legends BBCL 4002-2 (1998)
This recording was broadcast on 1960/9/23 by BBC Radio.
1961/2/25， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: Nikolai Kustov
LP: Old Melodiya D 09615/7 (1962)， 3 sides in 2 disc set B-560
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 8026 (1998)， 4 disc set
LP: Bruno 14064L (1965)
1982/3/27 or 28， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: na
CD: Philips 422442-2PH (1989)
CD: Philips 422442-2PX (1998)
CD: Icone ICN 9411-2 (1994)
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10917 (1996)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Philips 422442-2PH， Icone ICN 9411-2 and Russian Disc RDCD 10917 are identical， since the coughs in the first movement occur in the same places. Icone ICN 9411-2 incorrectly claims to have been recorded at the Concert Hall of the Moscow Radio on 1983/3/15. Japanese liner note attached to Philips 422442-2PH gives 1982/3/28 for the recording date. Russian Disc RDCD 10917 gives 1982/3/27 for the recording date.
Symphony No. 10 in e minor， Op. 93
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1953/12/17 in Leningrad
<1954/4/24， probably Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: na
LP: Old Melodiya D 02243/4 (1954) B-560， WERM3-426
LP: Melodiya D 032508/9 (1972)
LP: Melodiya S10 28431/4: Allegro only， 2 disc set
LP: Artia MK 1523 (1954)
LP: Chant du Monde LDXA 8113 (1954) WERM3-426
LP: Chant du Monde LDX 8113 (1967)
LP: Classics Club X 1018
LP: Colosseum CRLP 173 (1954)
LP: Concert Hall CHS 1313 (1954) WERM3-426
LP: Saga XID 5228 (1964)
CD: Saga Classics SCD 9017 (Disc claims stereo.)
CD: Saga Classics EC 3366-2 (1992)
LP: Shinsekai PLS 1 (1956)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7754 (1972)
LP: Shinsekai MK 1026 (1973)
The recording date was given by Aleksandr Nevzorov (Mravinsky’s last pupil). Colosseum CRLP 173 incorrectly claims to have been conducted by the Composer.
1976/3/3， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
CD: JVC VDC 25027 (1989)
CD: JVC VICC 40145 (1993)， 9 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40256 (1997)
CD: Erato 2292-45753-2 (1992)
1976/3/31， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: Gerhaldt Tses
LP: Melodiya M10 44371/2 (1982)
CD: BMG 74321-25198-2 (1995)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 4513 (1982)
CD: JVC VICC 40121 (1992)， 6 disc set
CD: Leningrad Masters LM 1322 (1995)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Leningrad Masters LM 1322 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same and the coughs in the first movement appear in the same places. Paul Miller confirmed that JVC VDC 25027 and VICC 40121 are distinct by using variable speed recorders and making A-B comparisons.
Symphony No. 11 in g minor， "The Year 1905"， Op. 103
Leningrad premiere recording； World premiere by Nathan Rakhlin/USSR State Symphony Orchestra on 1957/10/30 in Moscow
1957/11/3， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: na
LP: Old Melodiya D 4808/11 (1958)， 25cm， 2 disc set
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 11157 (1993)
1959/2/2， Large Studio of Moscow Radio， Studio， Monaural； RE: Aleksandr Grosman
LP: Old Melodiya D 06295/7 (1960)， 3 sides of 2 disc set B-560
LP: Artia MK 210B (1960)， 3 sides of 2 disc set
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4025 (1997)
CD: JVC VICC 40122 (1992)， 6 disc set
CD: Praga PR 254018 (1994)
CD: Revelation RV 10091 (1997)
LP: Shinsekai PX 5525 (1962)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7710 (1969)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7755 (1972)
LP: Shinsekai MK 1027 (1973)
Hiroshi Yasuda indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 254018 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4025 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same， and furthermore PR 254018 sounds like a studio recording. Praga PR 254018 incorrectly claims to be the live recording in 1967 in Prague. Revelation RV 10091 incorrectly dated 1959/11/2.
Symphony No. 12 in d minor， "The Year 1917"， Op. 112
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1961/10/1 in Leningrad
1961， Large Studio of Moscow Radio， Studio； RE: Aleksandr Grosman
MRAVINSKY’S LAST STUDIO RECORDING
LP: Old Melodiya D 09395/6 (1962)， Monaural B-560
LP: Melodiya S 0245/6 (1962) B-560
LP: Angel SR 40128 (1971)
LP: Artia MK 1580 (1964)
LP: Ariola 74485KK (1967)
LP: Ariola 74485MK (1976)
LP: Ariola XP 87620XK in XP 87623XK (1974)， 13 disc set
LP: Ariola 203637
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4026 (1997)
LP: Bruno BR 14065L (1964)
LP: Chant du Monde LDX 78465
LP: HMV ASD 2598 (1970)
LP: HMV 502510 in SLS 5025， 13 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 5005 (1976)
LP: JVC VIC 9533 (1984)
CD: JVC VDC 1122 (1986)
CD: JVC VICC 40123 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Phonogram 409
CD: Praga PR 254017 (1994)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7501 (1962)
LP: Shinsekai PX 5531 (1962)
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7538 (1968)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7538 (1968)
CD: Urania US 5162-CD (1989)
Artia MK 1580 and Urania US 5162-CD incorrectly claim to be the world premiere performance， with the latter stating that the Composer attended. Paul Miller confirmed that JVC VICC 40123， Artia MK 1580， and Urania US 5162-CD are all identical using variable speed recorders and by making A-B comparisons. Hiroshi Yasuda indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 254017 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4026 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same， and， furthermore， because PR 254017 sounds like a studio recording. Praga PR 254017 incorrectly claims to be the live recording on 1962/1/6 in Prague. JVC VDC 1122 incorrectly claims to be the concert at the Grand Hall of the Leningrad Philharmonic.
1984/4/29 or 30， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
MRAVINSKY’S LAST RECORDING
CD: JVC VDC 25028 (1989)
CD: JVC VICC 40146 (1993)， 9 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40257 (1997)
CD: Erato 2292-45754-2 (1992)
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10912 (1996)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that JVC VDC 25028 and Russian Disc RDCD 10912 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. JVC VDC 25028 gives 1984/4/30 for the recording date. Russian Disc RDCD 10912 gives 1984/4/29 for the recording date.
Symphony No. 15 in A， Op. 141
1972/5/5 or 6， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: Kh. Minakova
LP: Melodiya M10 43653/4 (1982)， 2 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 28053 (1981)
1976/5/26， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
LP: Melodiya S10 19299/300 (1983)
CD: Melodiya MCD 224 (1988)
CD: MCD 5002， 6 disc set
CD: Melodiya MCD 008: 3rd movement only
CD: BMG 74321-25192-2 (1995)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4032 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 28147 (1984)
CD: JVC VDC 1123 (1986)
CD: JVC VICC 2037 (1990)
CD: JVC VICC 40123 (1992)， 6 disc set
CD: Olympia OCD 224 (1988)
CD: Olympia OCD 5002， 6 disc set
CD: Olympia OCD 008: 3rd movement only
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46070-2 (1994)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46157-2 (1995)
Paul Miller confirmed that JVC VIC 28053 and JVC VDC 1123 are distinct by using variable speed recorders and by making A-B comparisons. JVC VDC 1123 incorrectly dated 1976/3/26.
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46157-2 and JVC VDC 1123 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46070-2 incorrectly dated 1976/6/3.
BMG(Japan) BVCX 4032 is incorrectly tracked between the second movement and the third movement.
评论
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
别组装了，买一套穆拉文斯基的吧 （ERATO）
--------
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
Mravinsky没有录过全集，他只录过5、6、7、8、10、11、12、15。
在ERATO只有76年录的10、84年录的5、12。
--------
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
海丁克的凑和
--------
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
那别的都是哪里出的？
--------
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
以下是Mravinsky的Shostakovich交响乐录音：
Symphony No. 5 in d minor， Op. 47
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1937/11/21 in Leningrad
1938/3/27 to 4/3， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: unknown
MRAVINSKY’S FIRST RECORDING
78: Old Melodiya 06820/33， 14 sides WERM1-559
CD: BMG(Japan) B0CC 3 (1998)， bonus disc in 4 disc set
This recording was broadcast on BBC Radio 3 on 1994/11/15. Melodiya does not have any original source of this recording.
late 1938 to early 1939， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: unknown
MRAVINSKY’S FIRST RECORDING AFTER BEING APPOINTED CHIEF CONDUCTOR OF THE LENINGRAD PHILHARMONIC
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 8020 (1998)， 4 disc set
1954/4/3， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: David Gaklin
LP: Old Melodiya D 02283/4 (1954) B-560， WERM3-426
LP: Ariola SQ 89519XDK (1976)， 2 disc set
CD: BMG 74321-29404-2 (1996)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4016 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 5075 (1977)
LP: JVC VICX 1006 (1979)， 10 disc set
CD: JVC VDC 25004 (1988)
LP: Kawade-shobo/Shinsekai SKV 1101 (1971)， 2 disc set
CD: Pigeon GX 248
LP: Shinsekai LS 4 (1956)
LP: Shinsekai PX 5501 (1961)
LP: Shinsekai PX 8539 (1964)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7583 (1965)， Electronic simulated stereo
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7592 (1970)， Electronic simulated stereo
LP: Shinsekai MK 1022 (1973)
LP: Vanguard VRS 6025 (1956)
Ariola SQ 89519XDK incorrectly claims this is the live recording on 1954/4/26 in Moscow.
1965/11/24， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: na
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10910 (1995)
1966， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: na
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 11023 (1993)
CD: Audiophile APL 101.503 (1994)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Audiophile APL 101.503 and Russian Disc RDCD 11023 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. Audiophile APL 101.503 incorrectly dated 1983.
Unknown date， Spring Festival in Prague， Live， Monaural； RE: na
CD: Hunt 2HUNTCD 714 (1990)， 2 disc set
CD: Arkadia CDGI 714.2， 2 disc set
Hunt 2HUNTCD 714 and Arkadia CDGI 714.2 incorrectly dated 1968. Mravinsky and the Leningrad Philharmonic did not visit Prague in 1968. Probably the date is 1967.
1973/6/29， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: na
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 11180 (1994)
The recording date was given by Aleksandr Nevzorov (Mravinsky’s last pupil).
1978/6/13， Vienna， Grosser Musikvereinssaal， Live； RE: Arfred Tsafrel
LP: Ariola 300666 in 300668-400 (1980)， 4 disc set
CD: Ariola 880028-910
LP: HMV ASD 4028 SLS 5212 (1980)， 4 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 2324 (1981)， 4 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 28017 (1981)
CT: JVC VCC 10006
CD: JVC VDC 1007 (1985)
CD: JVC VICC 40118 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Melodiya S10 15321/2 (1981)
CD: Praga PR 250085 (1994)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46021-2 (1994)
Daisuke Kisagami indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 250085 is identical with JVC VDC 1007， since the timings of the individual movements are same， and the coughs in the first movement are placed in the same places. Praga PR 250085 incorrectly claims to have been recorded on 1967/5/26 in Prague.
1984/4/4， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
CD: JVC VDC 25026 (1989)
CD: JVC VICC 40144 (1993)， 9 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40255 (1997)
CD: Erato 2292-45752-2 (1992)
CD: Icone ICN 9407-2 (1994)
CD: Leningrad Masters LM 1311 (1995)
Symphony No. 6 in b minor， Op. 54
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1939/11/5 in Leningrad
1946/11/4， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: unknown
LP: Old Melodiya D 2488/9 (1955)， 25cm B-560
LP: Melodiya D 030616 (1971) B-560
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4016 (1997)
LP: Chant du Monde LDXA 8267， 25cm
LP: JVC VIC 5076 (1977)
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7595 (1970)
LP: Shinsekai MK 1023 (1973)
1965/2/21， Grand Hall of Moscow Conservatory， Live； RE: Igor Veprintsev
LP: Melodiya SM 02857 (1971) B-560
LP: Melodiya S10 12955/6 (1980)
LP: Melodiya S60 12957/8 (1980): 2nd and 3rd movements only
LP: Angel SR 40202 (1972)
LP: Ariola 80586KK
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4028 (1997)
LP: HMV ASD 2805 (1972)
CD: Icone ICN 9404-2 (1994)
LP: JVC VIC 5068 (1977)
CD: JVC VICC 40118 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7711 (1972)
LP: Shinsekai MKX 2011 (1975)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46156-2 (1995)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46157-2 (1995)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that JVC VICC 40118， Icone ICN 9404-2， ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46156-2 and MEL 46157-2 are all identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. Icone ICN 9404-2 incorrectly claims to have been recorded at the Concert Hall of the Moscow Radio on 1983/3/12. JVC VICC 40118 incorrectly dated 1965/2/25.
1972/1/27， Grand Hall of Moscow Conservatory， Live； RE: Igor Veprintsev
CD: BMG 74321-25198-2 (1995)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 (1996)
CD: Praga PR 254017 (1994)
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10910 (1995)
Hiroshi Yasuda indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 254017 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 are identical， since the coughs in the second movement occur in the same places. Praga PR 254017 incorrectly claims to have been recorded on 1955/5/21 in Prague. Russian Disc RDCD 10910 incorrectly claims to have been recorded at the Grand Hall of the Leningrad Philharmonic.
Symphony No. 7 in C， "Leningrad"， Op. 60
<1953/2/26， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: Ilya Grodzensky
LP: Old Melodiya D 01380/3 (1953)， 2 discs B-560， WERM3-426
LP: Melodiya D 033449/51 (1972)， 3 sides in 2 disc set B-560
CD: BMG 74321-29405-2 (1996)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4017 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 5077/8 (1977)， 2 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40119 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Shinsekai PLS 28/9 (1957)， 2 disc set
LP: Shinsekai PX 8557/8 (1965)， 3 sides in 2 disc set
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7593/4 (1970)， 2 disc set
LP: Shinsekai MK 1024/5 (1973)， 2 disc set
LP: Vanguard VRS 6030/1 (1957)， 3 sides in 2 disc set
The recording date was given by Aleksandr Nevzorov (Mravinsky’s last pupil).
JVC VICC 40119 dated 1953/2/26.
Symphony No. 8 in c minor， Op. 65
Dedicated to Mravinsky
World premiere by Mravinsky/USSR State Symphony Orchestra on 1943/11/4 in Moscow
1947/6/2， Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: Ilya Grodzensky
LP: Old Melodiya D 03620/1 (1957) B-560
LP: Melodiya D 032639/40 (1972) B-560
LP: Ariola SQ 89519XDK (1976)， 3 sides in 2 disc set
LP: Artia MK 219B (1964)， 2 disc set
CD: BMG 74321-29406-2 (1996)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4018 (1997)
CD: JVC VICC 40120 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Shinsekai MK 1081 (1975)
1960/9/23， London， Royal Festival Hall， Live， the Composer in attendance； RE: na
CD: BBC Legends BBCL 4002-2 (1998)
This recording was broadcast on 1960/9/23 by BBC Radio.
1961/2/25， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: Nikolai Kustov
LP: Old Melodiya D 09615/7 (1962)， 3 sides in 2 disc set B-560
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 8026 (1998)， 4 disc set
LP: Bruno 14064L (1965)
1982/3/27 or 28， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: na
CD: Philips 422442-2PH (1989)
CD: Philips 422442-2PX (1998)
CD: Icone ICN 9411-2 (1994)
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10917 (1996)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Philips 422442-2PH， Icone ICN 9411-2 and Russian Disc RDCD 10917 are identical， since the coughs in the first movement occur in the same places. Icone ICN 9411-2 incorrectly claims to have been recorded at the Concert Hall of the Moscow Radio on 1983/3/15. Japanese liner note attached to Philips 422442-2PH gives 1982/3/28 for the recording date. Russian Disc RDCD 10917 gives 1982/3/27 for the recording date.
Symphony No. 10 in e minor， Op. 93
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1953/12/17 in Leningrad
<1954/4/24， probably Leningrad， Studio， Monaural； RE: na
LP: Old Melodiya D 02243/4 (1954) B-560， WERM3-426
LP: Melodiya D 032508/9 (1972)
LP: Melodiya S10 28431/4: Allegro only， 2 disc set
LP: Artia MK 1523 (1954)
LP: Chant du Monde LDXA 8113 (1954) WERM3-426
LP: Chant du Monde LDX 8113 (1967)
LP: Classics Club X 1018
LP: Colosseum CRLP 173 (1954)
LP: Concert Hall CHS 1313 (1954) WERM3-426
LP: Saga XID 5228 (1964)
CD: Saga Classics SCD 9017 (Disc claims stereo.)
CD: Saga Classics EC 3366-2 (1992)
LP: Shinsekai PLS 1 (1956)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7754 (1972)
LP: Shinsekai MK 1026 (1973)
The recording date was given by Aleksandr Nevzorov (Mravinsky’s last pupil). Colosseum CRLP 173 incorrectly claims to have been conducted by the Composer.
1955/6/3， Prague， Smetana Hall， Live， Monaural； RE: na
CD: Praga PR 250053 (1994)
1976/3/3， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
CD: JVC VDC 25027 (1989)
CD: JVC VICC 40145 (1993)， 9 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40256 (1997)
CD: Erato 2292-45753-2 (1992)
1976/3/31， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: Gerhaldt Tses
LP: Melodiya M10 44371/2 (1982)
CD: BMG 74321-25198-2 (1995)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 4513 (1982)
CD: JVC VICC 40121 (1992)， 6 disc set
CD: Leningrad Masters LM 1322 (1995)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Leningrad Masters LM 1322 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4007 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same and the coughs in the first movement appear in the same places. Paul Miller confirmed that JVC VDC 25027 and VICC 40121 are distinct by using variable speed recorders and making A-B comparisons.
Symphony No. 11 in g minor， "The Year 1905"， Op. 103
Leningrad premiere recording； World premiere by Nathan Rakhlin/USSR State Symphony Orchestra on 1957/10/30 in Moscow
1957/11/3， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: na
LP: Old Melodiya D 4808/11 (1958)， 25cm， 2 disc set
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 11157 (1993)
1959/2/2， Large Studio of Moscow Radio， Studio， Monaural； RE: Aleksandr Grosman
LP: Old Melodiya D 06295/7 (1960)， 3 sides of 2 disc set B-560
LP: Artia MK 210B (1960)， 3 sides of 2 disc set
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4025 (1997)
CD: JVC VICC 40122 (1992)， 6 disc set
CD: Praga PR 254018 (1994)
CD: Revelation RV 10091 (1997)
LP: Shinsekai PX 5525 (1962)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7710 (1969)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7755 (1972)
LP: Shinsekai MK 1027 (1973)
Hiroshi Yasuda indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 254018 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4025 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same， and furthermore PR 254018 sounds like a studio recording. Praga PR 254018 incorrectly claims to be the live recording in 1967 in Prague. Revelation RV 10091 incorrectly dated 1959/11/2.
Symphony No. 12 in d minor， "The Year 1917"， Op. 112
World premiere by Mravinsky/Leningrad Philharmonic on 1961/10/1 in Leningrad
1961， Large Studio of Moscow Radio， Studio； RE: Aleksandr Grosman
MRAVINSKY’S LAST STUDIO RECORDING
LP: Old Melodiya D 09395/6 (1962)， Monaural B-560
LP: Melodiya S 0245/6 (1962) B-560
LP: Angel SR 40128 (1971)
LP: Artia MK 1580 (1964)
LP: Ariola 74485KK (1967)
LP: Ariola 74485MK (1976)
LP: Ariola XP 87620XK in XP 87623XK (1974)， 13 disc set
LP: Ariola 203637
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4026 (1997)
LP: Bruno BR 14065L (1964)
LP: Chant du Monde LDX 78465
LP: HMV ASD 2598 (1970)
LP: HMV 502510 in SLS 5025， 13 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 5005 (1976)
LP: JVC VIC 9533 (1984)
CD: JVC VDC 1122 (1986)
CD: JVC VICC 40123 (1992)， 6 disc set
LP: Phonogram 409
CD: Praga PR 254017 (1994)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7501 (1962)
LP: Shinsekai PX 5531 (1962)
LP: Shinsekai SMK 7538 (1968)
LP: Shinsekai SH 7538 (1968)
CD: Urania US 5162-CD (1989)
Artia MK 1580 and Urania US 5162-CD incorrectly claim to be the world premiere performance， with the latter stating that the Composer attended. Paul Miller confirmed that JVC VICC 40123， Artia MK 1580， and Urania US 5162-CD are all identical using variable speed recorders and by making A-B comparisons. Hiroshi Yasuda indicated and Kenzo Amoh confirmed that Praga PR 254017 and BMG(Japan) BVCX 4026 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same， and， furthermore， because PR 254017 sounds like a studio recording. Praga PR 254017 incorrectly claims to be the live recording on 1962/1/6 in Prague. JVC VDC 1122 incorrectly claims to be the concert at the Grand Hall of the Leningrad Philharmonic.
1984/4/29 or 30， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
MRAVINSKY’S LAST RECORDING
CD: JVC VDC 25028 (1989)
CD: JVC VICC 40146 (1993)， 9 disc set
CD: JVC VICC 40257 (1997)
CD: Erato 2292-45754-2 (1992)
CD: Russian Disc RDCD 10912 (1996)
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that JVC VDC 25028 and Russian Disc RDCD 10912 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. JVC VDC 25028 gives 1984/4/30 for the recording date. Russian Disc RDCD 10912 gives 1984/4/29 for the recording date.
Symphony No. 15 in A， Op. 141
1972/5/5 or 6， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live， Monaural； RE: Kh. Minakova
LP: Melodiya M10 43653/4 (1982)， 2 disc set
LP: JVC VIC 28053 (1981)
1976/5/26， Grand Hall of Leningrad Philharmonic， Live； RE: Semyon Shugal
LP: Melodiya S10 19299/300 (1983)
CD: Melodiya MCD 224 (1988)
CD: MCD 5002， 6 disc set
CD: Melodiya MCD 008: 3rd movement only
CD: BMG 74321-25192-2 (1995)
CD: BMG(Japan) BVCX 4032 (1997)
LP: JVC VIC 28147 (1984)
CD: JVC VDC 1123 (1986)
CD: JVC VICC 2037 (1990)
CD: JVC VICC 40123 (1992)， 6 disc set
CD: Olympia OCD 224 (1988)
CD: Olympia OCD 5002， 6 disc set
CD: Olympia OCD 008: 3rd movement only
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46070-2 (1994)
CD: ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46157-2 (1995)
Paul Miller confirmed that JVC VIC 28053 and JVC VDC 1123 are distinct by using variable speed recorders and by making A-B comparisons. JVC VDC 1123 incorrectly dated 1976/3/26.
Kenzo Amoh confirmed that ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46157-2 and JVC VDC 1123 are identical， since the timings of the individual movements are same. ZYX/Melodiya MEL 46070-2 incorrectly dated 1976/6/3.
BMG(Japan) BVCX 4032 is incorrectly tracked between the second movement and the third movement.
--------
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
十分感谢。
不过大多数在国内都难买到，
我只见过bbc出的第8和mozart No.33的双张
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
辛苦了。
--------
RE: 如果组装一套shostakovich交响曲全集，你会选哪些版本？
感谢，感谢，我去一张一张找。
--------